It has been five years. Five years since I’ve posted on this blog and five years since I updated EOM. I want to say the world has changed, and in many ways it has. Some for the better. Chapter 83 (where James finds out getting a marriage license is impossible) was written before gay marriage was legalized in the United States. So hurrah! (It would be a surprise to no one who reads EOM that real-life issues inspire many elements in the story.)
But more obviously, the world has become a darker place. I am from the United States, and while the world as a whole is dealing with Covid19, here there has been a steady dissolution, or hollowing out, of the institutions that make democracy possible.
In the last few chapters of EOM, we saw specific groups in society arrested with no provocation and often killed in the process–those in law enforcement facing no consequences. This has not changed in five years.
In chapter 83, a panellist on a radio programme said, “Wizarding world for wizards,” and that muggleborns should be locked up or not allowed entry into the wizarding world. This was written before Donald Trump’s presidency. White nationalism was already alive and thriving, but the Trump presidency has invigorated and (seemingly) legitimized it. But this is a post for another time.
Also, I would like to take this opportunity to apologize now for future chapters. I took a five-year break. An athlete who does not train her body for five years will not perform at the level she did at the peak of her career. So it is with me.
I wrote most of Chapter 84 a long time ago, and it (and I) got stuck in a dark place. Azkaban is not a happy place for your mind to be stuck. (Spoiler alert- dementors = depression. That feeling like you’ll never be cheerful again? And I could no more write my way out of that chapter than I could write my way out of depression. Indeed, I’m still in Azkaban, I’m pretty much always in Azkaban.
Just some days the dementors are nearer than others.
But mental health is also a post for another time.)
So at the time of publishing chapter 84, mostly old work, I was struggling to write the chapter that is to follow. My writing is weak— my creative muscles are barely capable of lifting a pen. I know I’m a worse writer than I was five years ago.
Blogging will be my cross-training—reflective non-fiction to do in between daily prose sprints. (I’ve also started running during the pandemic, and I’m afraid the mindset is leaking into my other pursuits.)
I often fear that two fanfictions, EOM and Professor’s Discretion, will be the best work of my life. I’m certainly proud of PD, it’s the only writing endeavour I’ve ever finished and been satisfied. I’ve never gone so deep—politically, emotionally, and in terms of plot— in my original fiction as I have with those two. But those characters were already formed, people’s attachment to them already steadfast. I cannot create that from scratch, nor carry over the care I took with those. I don’t know that I can do it again, even now.
And as I was going back through previous chapters to prepare to work on the next, I was surprised by my own writing—everything I’ve written recently is so staid and colourless. I was actually impressed with past me, at the description and the depth and the intricacies of it, and disappointed with the present me. I tried to write up the rest of the chapter but couldn’t. I tried multiple times. Somehow, I couldn’t get any traction, couldn’t find any footholds. I just couldn’t get a purchase on the story to pull it, and myself, forward.
Until one day (yesterday, as it so happens), by some miracle, I found the old falling apart notebook in an old backpack that had fallen apart, but I hadn’t been able to bring myself to throw away because it had given me ten years of faithful service and I kept telling myself I’d find some use for it. The notebook inside contained 76 pages of chapter 84 and parts of Chapter 85.
The notebook itself I bought in Serbia and I’d taken it with me all around the Balkens. Inside the old thing was a single-page print out map of a city where I had stayed—Prizren, in Kosovo.
It was folded and tattered, but I opened it, and on the back, in blood-brown ink, was part of what will be the next chapter. And I suddenly remembered.
In Prizren, there is a tall hill. Near the top, was a cafe, perhaps there still is. I had had spent the better part of an afternoon hiking up it. My plan had been to tarry in the cafe a while and write, but I finally got there only to find I had somehow managed to come all that way without my notebook. I had the map of the city though, and filled the page with tiny handwriting.
I can’t believe I used to write it longhand. I have written over half of EOM with pen and paper. Half a million words. So many notebooks. Where are they now? (I know one is in Saldanha Bay, South Africa, when both notebook and I took a tumble into the drink.)
Did my hands used to cramp? I don’t remember.
I have therefore decided to write EOM in by hand, rather than on the computer. It might solve part of the problem.
Another might be that I’ve always written elsewhere. Travelling and writing were part of the same process. If I travelled, I wrote. If I was writing, I was travelling. But now I am implacably stuck at home. No real possibilities of the yonder.
At least I know I’m not alone with this.
In any case, here’s to trying again.
~Kathryn
Let me know in the comments below any questions or topics you’d be interested in hearing about! (I can’t promise to answer all questions completely, but I’ll do my best!)
10 replies on “For Readers of Every Other Midnight,”
This is far and away my favorite multi chapter fanfic. Reading that you have decided to come back to it is the most heartening news. I know it’s hard to pick something back up when you’re out of practice, but the courage you display in getting back on the horse anyway is inspiring. I can’t wait to read the results!
I am truly happy you decided to come back to EOM. It is one of those stories I’ve followed for a long time and every once in a while revist to see if there’s anything new. I’m happy to know there will be new chapters.
Take your time and I hope you enjoy writing. I can tell you I, and many others, enjoy reading.
I really hope you continue with EOM if or when you feel mentally ready. It has brought so many people joy, myself included, and I’m looking forward to seeing the rest of it play out. I certainly wouldn’t mind even a rough outline of the rest of the plot if you don’t feel up for finishing it. It’s also perfectly okay to be rough at writing— anything you write will enrapture me. Good luck and stay safe!
I’m so happy to have stumbled across your update. It was a pleasure getting to connect several years ago over Twitter, and I think fondly of our conversations. Holding you in my thoughts that you’ve managed to find some chocolate to bring you a bit of brightness in your Azkaban. Your writing has always stuck with me, with how powerful and real your storyline was to real life- and I reread it over the last year and was struck by how it was more relevant than ever.
Kathryn – thank you for dedicating so much of your life to EOM. It is one of the most incredible works of fiction I’ve read. The story is so intricate and the characters are so well crafted. I picked this fic up probably 7-10 years ago and I abandoned around the time that Lily and James got together initially because I was hoping it would be an easy ride for them once they admitted their feelings for one another. During the midst of the pandemic I went back to reread all of the great Jily fics and I wanted to give Every Other Midnight another shot. I’m so glad I did. This fic is canon to me. I don’t think there’s a fic out there with better characterization of Lily and all the Marauders, even Snape. The world you created is so grounded in canon roots that I still can’t figure out if this will lead to their canon ending or if you’ll write your own. Another thank you for spending so much time on the secondary characters in the story. I think the well-rounded, so incredibly human and flawed characters make your story that much more compelling. I look forward to the coming chapters that you have for your readers, no matter how long it takes! I will be here supporting your writing whenever you feel ready to share.
I discovered this blog after reading ‘the Professor’s Discretion’. I have read and re-read the posts here, savoring the natural yet refined writing – it is not easy to find words carefully put together in this terribly information-overloaded cyber age.
I myself had dreamed of being a writer, but life had led me to a wildly different path. Now even I see the dream flying away like dandelions, I still get inspired from time to time by good authors. I haven’t started ‘Every Other Midnight’ due to its length, but the Professor’s Discretion and those essays, and even the book reviews you wrote could convince me that I’ve made very good use of my time.
I was using HP fanfics to fight depression but am glad that I got the opportunity to read the Professor’s Discretion, which then led to the discovery of other amazing writings of yours. I am not sure if you will see this since the post is 6 month old, but if you do please remember that there are readers who truly and greatly appreciate your works. Keep it up and I believe your talents will bring fulfillment to both you and readers (like me)
<3
I have read EOM at least 4 times. I started reading it back when you first started writing it and it will always be one of the best things I have ever read. I actually hope JK Rowling never writes a prequel because it will never be able to be anywhere near as good as what you have written. It has brought so many people such happiness. I may actually go back and read it again a 5th time. 🙂
Like some others I started reading Every Other Midnight years ago, but I recently found it again, and I was totally consumed. EOM may be categorized as “just” fanfiction, but your writing is much better than so many of the professionally published books I’ve read. I know a lot of my writer friends tend to be pretty self-critical with their work (or totally arrogant lol), but just because you may not be 100% satisfied with the next chapter, doesn’t mean any of your readers would be remotely bothered by whatever flaws you perceive. And I think I speak for a lot of your fans when I say we’d happily read anything you wrote. I’m really looking forward to the next chapter, and I expect to keep hanging on until the end! I hope you are doing well these days & here’s hoping this year goes better than 2020 for us all!
<3